2022
See MG 5 for saleMG 5
From EGP 268,000
MG 5 vs Proton Saga: Which Should You Buy in Egypt?
A complete comparison of the MG 5 VS Proton Saga — specs, prices, pros and cons, and live used listings across Egypt.
2022
See Proton Saga for saleProton Saga
From EGP 188,900
MG 5 VS Proton Saga: the verdict
The MG 5 emerges as the overall winner for buyers prioritizing performance, space, and a more refined driving experience. With its stronger 112 hp engine and larger 512 L trunk, it offers greater utility and comfort. However, the Proton Saga presents a compelling counter-argument for budget-conscious shoppers, offering significant savings at a more accessible price point starting from 166,900 EGP.
| #1 MG 5#1 | #2 Proton Saga#2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price Comparison | ||
| Starting at | 228,000 – 268,000 EGP | 166,900 – 188,900 EGP |
| Engine & Power | ||
| Engine | 1,500 cc · 4 cyl | 1,332 cc · 4 – 5 cyl |
| Horsepower (bhp) | 112 hp | 94 – 95 hp |
| Torque (Nm) | 150 Nm | 120 – 121 Nm |
| Acceleration 0-100 Km/h (sec) | 11.5 s | 13 – 14.5 s |
| Top Speed (Km/h) | 180 km/h | 155 – 160 km/h |
| Fuel Economy (L/100 Km) | 5.5 – 6.4 L/100km | 5.9 – 6.5 L/100km |
| Fuel Tank Capacity | 45 L | 40 L |
| Gears | — | 5 |
| Transmission | CVT | Automatic / Manual |
| Drive Type | Front Wheel Drive | Front Wheel Drive |
| Fuel Type | Petrol | Petrol |
| Measurements | ||
| L×W×H | 4.6 m × 1.8 m × 1.5 m | 4.3 m × 1.7 m × 1.5 m |
| Wheelbase (meters) | 2.7 m | 2.5 m |
| Curb Weight (kg) | 1,185 – 1,230 kg | 1,065 – 1,075 kg |
| Trunk Capacity (liters) | 512 L | 413 L |
| Overview | ||
| Body Style | Sedan | Sedan |
| Seating Capacity | 5 seats | 5 seats |
| Doors | 4 doors | 4 doors |
| Features | ||
| Key features | 360-Degree Camera360-Degree CameraABS (Anti-lock Brake System)Acoustic HoodActive SteeringAirbagsAlloy PedalsAnti theft alarmAnti-theft Wheel BoltsAuto Door LockAuto HeadlampsAutomatic ACAUXBluetoothBody Colored GrilleCD PlayerCenter Arm RestCentral LockingChrome Door HandlesChrome Exhaust PipesClimate ControlCollision DetectionDifferential LockDisc BrakesEBD (Electronic Brakeforce Distribution)Electric Door MirrorsElectric Opening and Closing of Luggage DoorFire ExtinguisherFirst Aid KitFog Lamps - Front OnlyGas Shock AbsorberHDMIHeadlampsHID HeadlightsHill AssistImmobilizerISOFIX Child Seat AnchorsLeather SeatsLED Fog LightsLED HeadlightsLegroomMP3MudguardMulti-Information DisplayMulti-Information Display SizeNight VisionOBD (On-board Diagnostics)Off-Road DampersParking SensorsPedestrian airbagPower MirrorsPower SeatsPower SteeringPower TailgatePower WindowsPower Windows - Front and RearPush Button StartRacing Or Bucket SeatsRear AC ControlsRear Audio ControlsRear CameraRear Lcd screensSingle Exhaust TipSpare WheelSpeed Sensitive Windshield WipersSpoilerSurround CameraTiptronic GearsUSB PortVariable Cylinder Management (VCM)Vehicle Stability Control (VSC)Wheel SizeWheels - AlloyWinchWireless HeadphonesWood Trim | 360-Degree Camera360-Degree CameraABS (Anti-lock Brake System)Acoustic HoodActive SteeringAirbagsAluminum WheelsAnti theft alarmAUXBA (Brake Assist)BluetoothCentral LockingChrome Door HandlesChrome Exhaust PipesClimate ControlCollision DetectionDoor Mirrors with Side Turn SignalEBD (Electronic Brakeforce Distribution)Fabric SeatsFire ExtinguisherFirst Aid KitFog Lamp - Front and RearFoldable Rear Seats with 60:40 SplitFront BrakesGas Shock AbsorberHDMIImmobilizerISOFIX Child Seat AnchorsKeyless EntryLED Fog LightsMP3Multi-Information DisplayOBD (On-board Diagnostics)Off-Road DampersParking SensorsPedestrian airbagPower SteeringPower TailgateRadioSingle Exhaust TipSteering Tilt AdjustmentTraction ControlTyre Pressure Monitoring DisplayUrethane Steering WheelUSB PortVariable Cylinder Management (VCM)Wheel SizeWheels - AlloyWinchWireless Headphones |
Which one should you buy?
1
Best for Value
The Proton Saga is the undisputed champion for buyers seeking maximum value, with a significantly lower starting price of 166,900 EGP making it an excellent budget-friendly choice in Egypt.
2
Best for Performance
For those who desire more power and quicker acceleration, the MG 5 takes the lead. Its 112 hp engine and 11.5s acceleration offer a more dynamic and responsive driving experience.
3
Best for Families & Cargo
The MG 5 provides superior practicality for families and those needing ample cargo space, boasting a generous 512 L trunk capacity and a more spacious cabin thanks to its longer wheelbase.
4
Best for Fuel Efficiency
The MG 5 offers a slightly better fuel economy at its most efficient, consuming 5.5 L/100km, making it a more economical choice for daily commutes and long-term running costs.
Pros & cons
MG 5
Pros
- Higher 112 hp engine output
- Faster 11.5s acceleration to 100 km/h
- Significantly larger 512 L trunk capacity
- More spacious interior with longer 2.7 m wheelbase
- Better maximum fuel efficiency (5.5 L/100km)
Cons
- Higher purchase price starting from 228,000 EGP
- Heavier kerb weight (1,185 kg)
Proton Saga
Pros
- Significantly lower starting price (166,900 EGP)
- More compact and lighter for city maneuverability
- Option for a manual transmission
- Lower kerb weight (1,065 kg)
Cons
- Lower 94 hp engine power
- Slower 13s acceleration to 100 km/h
- Smaller 413 L trunk capacity
- Less fuel-efficient at its average (6.5 L/100km)
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the MG 5 or Proton Saga more affordable in Egypt?
The Proton Saga is significantly more affordable in Egypt, with prices starting from 166,900 EGP compared to the MG 5's starting price of 228,000 EGP. If budget is your primary concern, the Proton Saga offers excellent value and a lower entry point into the sedan segment.
Which car, MG 5 or Proton Saga, offers better performance?
The MG 5 clearly outperforms the Proton Saga. It boasts a 112 hp engine and accelerates from 0-100 km/h in 11.5 seconds, whereas the Proton Saga offers 94 hp and a slower 13-second acceleration. For a more dynamic driving experience with higher top speed, the MG 5 is the better choice.
Which is better for families: MG 5 or Proton Saga?
The MG 5 is superior for families due to its larger dimensions, longer 2.7 m wheelbase, and significantly more spacious 512 L trunk capacity, offering ample room for passengers and luggage. The Proton Saga's 413 L trunk and more compact interior might feel cramped for larger families or extensive cargo needs.
What is the fuel economy of the MG 5 compared to the Proton Saga?
The MG 5 generally offers better fuel economy, with its most efficient variant achieving 5.5 L/100km, compared to the Proton Saga's 5.9 L/100km at its best. For long-term running costs and fewer trips to the pump, the MG 5 has a slight edge in efficiency.
Is the MG 5 or Proton Saga easier to park in city traffic?
The Proton Saga is generally easier to park and maneuver in city traffic due to its more compact dimensions (4.3 m length vs MG 5's 4.6 m) and lighter kerb weight. Its smaller size makes it more agile and convenient in tight urban spaces and parking lots.
